- Flour mixed with epsom salt for the moon's powdery, rocky surface.
- Elbow Macaroni Crescent moon(s)
- Number 4 (from a number puzzle) as a reminder that the moon and stars are part of the fourth day of Creation
- Rocks (collected outside) as moon rocks/meteors, for dropping and making "craters"
- Cardboard glow in the dark full moon
- Glow in the dark stars